View of arbitrators

Burning question: Uber and Grab’s legal status

04/01/2018 09:45

Vietnamese lawyers suggest that Vietnam should manage Uber as a transportation firm using a ride-hailing application, based on the European Court of Justice (ECJ)’s decision that Uber is a taxi service.

vietnam economy, business news, vn news, vietnamnet bridge, english news, Vietnam news, news Vietnam, vietnamnet news, vn news, Vietnam net news, Vietnam latest news, Vietnam breaking news, Grab, Uber, Mai Linh

Emboldened by the ECJ's decision, Vietnamese lawyers call to re-label Uber and Grab Europe's top court ruled that Uber should be regulated as a transportation company and not a tech firm, forcing it to comply with national regulations that it has previously been able to ignore. The decision came only a day after the company was accused at a London court of becoming a menace to public safety by forcing its drivers to work exhausting hours.

Lawyer Truong Thanh Duc, representative of the Vietnam International Arbitration Centre (VIAC), said that the ECJ’s decision on Uber will not impact Uber’s legal status in Vietnam, however, it should provide momentum for local authorities to reconsider their stance.

According to Ha Huy Tu, representative of the Hanoi Lawyers Association, at present, local authorities have failed to properly manage Uber's operations as they have yet to issue a final decision about the legal nature of the company in Vietnam. Thus, ECJ’s decision should serve as a suggestion for Vietnam to build a better management policy for Uber. Tu also considers Uber as a transportation service company.

Duc added that Uber is a technology company operating in numerous countries under the “transportation in collaboration with technology” or technology taxi model.

However, Vietnam should list the operations of Uber in one of three models. First is a ride-hailing application in co-operation with professional taxi services. The second is a ride-hailing application in co-operation with private cars without having a business licence for taxi services but having a general business licence. The third is a ride-hailing application in co-operation with private cars without any business licence.

Duc stated that it would be the most constructive if Vietnam opted for the first model. Regarding the second and the third model, Vietnam needs to build close and flexible management policies to stimulate the transportation firms using technology to develop. 

Previously, right after the ECJ issued the decision on Uber, Ho Chi Minh City Taxi Association proposed the Ministry of Transport to identify Uber and Grab as taxi transportation firms. According to the association, if Uber affirms that it is just a tech firm, it is not permitted to build a fare table or directly sign contracts with taxi drivers. Besides, it is not permitted to use foreign capital on promotion and advertisement programmes to create unfair competition with traditional taxi companies.

In addition, Ta Long Hy, deputy general director of Vietnamese taxi company Vinasun, said the company would persist with suing Uber and Grab for unfair competition.

Hy said that either Vinasun or employees together will start a lawsuit. The three taxi associations of the three regions of Vietnam (north, south, and central) also signed a proposal to the Ministry of Industry and Trade asking for an investigation of the promotion activities.

Credit: VIR

Share Post
  • Another way to attract foreign investment 14/05/2019 11:33

    Most enterprises are not willing to increase their foreign ownership limit because when this ratio rises above 51% the companies will be treated as foreign investors. This will curtail several business areas and require companies to change investment criteria to that of foreign investor. Meanwhile, many foreign investors claim that it is very difficult to buy good stocks due to limit in foreign ownership in various companies.


  • Foreign businesses accelerate indirect investment in Vietnam 07/05/2019 10:04

    Vietnam high and steady economic growth in the past years has strongly drawn foreign capital and investment in local firms considered as the shortest way for foreign investors to enter the Vietnamese market.

  • Vietnam well-positioned to develop industrial property 07/05/2019 10:01

    Vietnam is well-positioned to develop industrial property, experts said at the Vietnam Industrial Real Estate Forum 2019 in Hanoi on April 23.


  • Vietnam mulls PPP Law with sovereign guarantees to reassure investors 19/04/2019 08:12

    A proposed new law envisages offering sovereign guarantees to attract private investment in large transport infrastructure projects.

  • Vietnamese companies urged to prepare for impacts of US-China trade spat 10/04/2019 09:50

    With trade protectionism increasing, Vietnamese companies should prepare for trade-related lawsuits and disputes but also capitalise on possible opportunities from the ongoing US-China trade war, a top trade remedy official has said.

  • Tax reform crucial for State budget sustainability 04/04/2019 10:02

    Taxes and duties are a very important source of State budget revenue and provide major finance for the Government’s socio-economic development programmes. In Việt Nam, tax revenue is starting to decline while expenditure continues to rise, threatening budget sustainability.

  • Việt Nam vows to improve business environment 27/02/2019 09:16

    Nguyễn Đình Cung, director of the Central Institute for Economic Management, arbitrator at Vietnam International Arbitration Centre, talks to Hải Quan (Customs Online) online newspaper about Việt Nam’s efforts to improve its business environment in 2019. 


  • Experts warn investors of legal risks in M&A transactions 04/01/2019 09:27

    Despite a slew of opportunities given to foreign investors to conduct merger and acquisition (M&A) transactions in Vietnam, investors might encounter legal risks when disputes arise.